Why we are glad we took part in the “A Vision for Rome” competition, why we are glad we won, and why we would do it again.
By Luigi Corvo, CEO of Open Impact and Associate Professor at the University of Milano-Bicocca

We are delighted that Roma Continua, the proposal Open Impact contributed to as part of an outstanding interdisciplinary team, has won the international competition “A Vision for Rome”, promoted by the Fondazione Roma REgeneration.
We are pleased with the result, of course. But above all, we are pleased with what it signals: a vision that tries to look at urban transformation as more than a question of form, function or economic return. For Open Impact, taking part in Roma Continua meant bringing into this process and into an urban vision a yardstick other than financial return alone: social, environmental and public value. Not as decoration, nor as language added at the end, but as a criterion for questioning transformations from the outset: who they create value for, with what effects, under what conditions, and with what tools for verifying it over time.
We are well aware that this position raises some difficult questions. Should those who work on the social and environmental value of the city take part in processes promoted by real estate and financial players, or should they stay out of them? Should those who try to measure the city by a yardstick other than financial return alone engage in arenas such as this competition, or keep their distance?
It is a serious question, and we have asked it of ourselves seriously. The “Spin Time case”, which I will discuss in more detail later, seems to make everything simpler and more vivid, because it brings to light a possible ethical conflict between being involved in that situation and proposing broader visions of the city. But the real question is bigger than any conflict or minor contradiction of ours. And that is the question we are interested in.
From a theoretical point of view, for those of us who do this work, the most interesting dynamic in this story is a different one: nobody was surprised that every project included an analysis of economic value, yet some were surprised that ours included an analysis of social value. As if economic value were taken by all of us as a “natural” and indispensable component. We do not even notice it: a proposal that fails to quantify the investment required and to address the revenue streams capable of generating a return is simply unthinkable. The presence of a preliminary analysis of social value, on the other hand, makes us stop and question. This, ultimately, is the effect of the capitalist religion we all live in: a religion that shapes not only our reasoning, but first and foremost our perceptions and desires.
What is happening to cities
Let us get to the heart of the matter. To do so, we need to refer to a structural trend in contemporary capitalism that is worth describing precisely, because it is the context in which everything else unfolds.
We are living through an extraordinary acceleration in the concentration of capital. This is harmful not only in terms of inequality, an important but by now well-worn argument, but also in terms of the intelligence of capital itself. When wealth is concentrated in a few hands, it loses access to the general intellect: the diffuse intelligence that arises from the many interactions between people, practices and places. And this makes capital short-sighted. Today, this hyper-concentrated capital moves between two spaces. The first is cyberspace: digital markets where returns are stellar, where the first mover wins and marginal costs tend towards zero. The second is physical space: land, property, infrastructure. And physical space acts as an osmotic reservoir for all the money that no longer finds room in the first, because it is too unstable and exposed to the risk of radical innovation.
Every time technological uncertainty triggers a “landslide” (a bubble that deflates, a valuation that collapses, a cycle that comes to an end), masses of capital seek refuge in physical space. And when they arrive, they bring a demand with them: for a space that is ordered, predictable and ready to receive them. This is what Heidegger called Gestell, or enframing: the setting-up of the world as an ordered, exploitable standing-reserve. Ban, from the same Proto-Germanic root as banlieue, bandit and banal, originally meant the proclamation of the feudal lord: the command that defines who belongs to a space and who is expelled from it. Banlieue is literally the territory within which that ban holds. Gestell inhabits this same logic: space made available, ordered, rendered exploitable by decree. When capital seeks refuge in a territory, it demands that the territory be “banally” ordered: cleared of complexity, ready for extraction.
The mechanism follows a precise logic of blackmail: if a territory is not willing to order itself around returns, then it is not “attractive”. And if it is not attractive, it does not “deserve” investment. Under these conditions, returns are not merely conceded: they are called for in chorus, by public administrations, by technical debate and often even by the third sector, as if they were the natural condition of urban development.
We see the social cost every day: structurally rising property prices, the gradual displacement of residents from city centres, and the growing impossibility of reconciling income from work with the cost of housing. And in the background, a systematic call for public intervention in the form of non-repayable grants, in other words funded by debt, in a country that is already the most indebted in Europe: eighty-five billion euros a year in interest alone, rising as the debt grows, taken away from healthcare, schools, research and culture. This is the condition we face: not a backdrop, but the field we work in.
Could we have “deserted”?
At this point the question becomes concrete: so what is to be done? The only alternative implied by a simplified reading is not to take part. It is a gesture we understand, and one with a certain discreet charm. But it is also a partly romantic gesture: it imagines it can halt a material process by staying symbolically outside it.
And we, having just looked at the city through a materialist lens, must ask ourselves two far more concrete questions: would it have helped, and would it have been feasible? A boycott only works if it is coordinated and collective, and thirty-five teams, hundreds of professionals, entered this competition: who would have organised that refusal, and on whose behalf? On your own, abstaining is not a boycott: it is an absence. And an absence stops nothing; it simply leaves one less voice in the room.
The other option, even worse, would have been to take part while leaving out precisely the expertise in social impact and gender-sensitive urban planning. In other words, handing down to future generations exactly the technical, market-driven vision we claim to fear, with no one left inside to ask “for whom, at what price, at whose expense”.
So why take part?
It is worth asking, then, what taking part in Rome ReGeneration actually produced. A project, first of all: a vision of Rome built over almost a year of shared work. And networks, between practices, researchers and organisations that previously did not talk to each other and are now generating ideas.
Above all, this story has produced something that would not exist without Open Impact’s choice: within the Roma Continua vision that won the competition, there is an impact measurement framework, with impact chains and indicators linked to expected outcomes and to the broader sustainability goals.
Not a technical exercise, but a way of never separating the city we imagine from the people who will have to live in it, and from what the transformation does to their lives. And alongside it, from the other expertise within the team, the perspective of those who read the city starting from people, down to the way inequalities, including gender inequalities, take shape in space.
The question to ask is simple: would that project, and those networks, have been better or worse without this perspective? For us, the answer is obvious.
Will impact and social innovation really be taken into account?
The hardest question remains, and in our view the most legitimate one: will these projects, with the social innovation they bring, really be taken seriously? What instrumental role do they play in the work of the funds? The risk of instrumentalisation always exists, and we do not deny it. But this is precisely why we chose to be inside rather than outside.
If that risk is real, there are two options: let investors use the mechanism with no one holding them to account, or be there, to make that use harder and to have, tomorrow, a yardstick by which to measure them against the very vision they chose to reward.
It is not a cover: it is a tool built today to be used when it is needed. Provided it is made permanent, as a standing forum that keeps measuring promises and holding people to account for the gap between what is announced and what is done. That is where a “vision” stops being an image and becomes a verifiable commitment. But this raises a question that I believe is crucial: how is the level of public interest determined in urban regeneration processes? In practical terms, what method and what tools enable public bodies to make decisions when they deal with investors?
Measuring is what we do
We have already shown that this can be done, and it can be verified. For Spin Time, Open Impact measured that every euro invested in its regularisation generates €1.95 of social value. We said so at Rome City Hall, in black and white, against the interests of the fund that owns the building and would rather turn it into a hotel. Not to “legitimise” Spin Time, which needs no one to legitimise it, but to make a simple point: the cost of building that hotel is not zero. That place has a name, a measure, and people who live there.
This is what we do: put a number on what others would rather leave unpriced, even, and above all, when those paying for our work sit on the other side of the table. We did it for Spin Time, we brought it to Roma Continua, and we will keep doing it, without hiding from either side.
Because impact does not apply only to what we consider good, beautiful or culturally close to us. It applies, and should apply, to everything we consider significant and, ideally, to everything for which there is an analysis of economic value. Because, as mentioned above, it should no longer seem “strange” to consider social value in processes that are uncomfortable, complex and contradictory. Only when we come to see the presence of economic value and social value as equally “natural” will we be able to say we have achieved a substantial transformation within, against and beyond the miseries of this stifling and “banal” model of development.
An invitation
We are not interested in this controversy as such. We are interested in the question it contains, which is a serious one: how do we build a collective mobilisation that is not merely identity-driven, defensive or twilight? How do we break out of the spiral we have described without simply holding the line against it from below? And to conclude, we turn this question into an invitation: to a public debate, with the data on the table, on impact evaluation as a political tool in urban transformation. On what it means to bring the general intellect into the processes that exclude it, rather than observing them from outside.